This is the week I will read a book for Valentine’s Day to first and second graders. I gave them a heads-up last week before leaving. I asked what they thought a book for Valentine’s should have. All six classes had answers like hearts, love, gifts, Valentines, red. One second grade girl had a most excellent answer–relationships. She is “right on” for the book I have to read–The Hating Book.
It’s a story of two friends who have a terrible misunderstanding and stop speaking to each other and doing some mean things to one another. Neither of them knows what the other is thinking. The narrator girl (neither girls have names) keeps saying, after each unkind event, “I hate, hate, hated my friend.” I point out, as I read the story, that she keeps calling her “my friend,” so I think we can say she still likes her.
This is another book about giving students words to express their feelings. Much like the girl in the book, Don’t Touch My Hair, who didn’t realize she had the power to stop people touching her hair if she just spoke up. Or the little bird in Let’s Go Hugo who was afraid to fly but had never told anyone of his fear. It’s a theme in many of the books: speak up, stand up, let people know what you are feeling, thinking, needing.
The Hating Book has a happy ending (you knew it would), but not before the girls have to confront their feelings and speak to one another. It reminds me of a situation when I was teaching high school seniors. I had a class of 12th graders right after lunch, students I knew really well, and one day a girl came in, a bit late, and very sad and dejected looking. I asked what was wrong.
Her boyfriend had not asked her to go out to lunch, off-campus.
“Did you tell him you wanted to go out for lunch,” I asked.
“No, but he should know I wanted to go out. He went with his friends instead.” Friends being a group of other guys.
I proceeded to explain to her that most people, and especially guys, can’t read your mind. You have to tell them what you want. That’s the lesson with The Hating Book. You must tell people what you are feeling and what you want.