Training vs educating

I would prefer to be an educator.  I would like to plan my lessons, walk into my classroom, present my material, give the students an assignment, and let them work.  I would like to walk around, giving advice, chatting, correcting, and getting a sense of how well my students are doing.  My yearbook class is pretty much this way, though I have a few trouble areas.  But nothing like my other classes.

I have kids who cannot sit still, who cannot listen, who cannot work without constant supervision, who constantly need me.  I have kids who do not come to class.  I have kids who come to class but don’t want to be there and refuse to do anything.  (This one young man is probably a whole blog post on his own.)  I have kids who do not bring their materials to class (like a flashdrive or usb cord for their camera) and so cannot work.  And these are high school students, juniors and seniors.

One student I have is constantly trying to figure out ways to get out of class.  He wanted to change classes but it was past the date to do so and he is required to stay in the class until the semester ends, which is only 16 weeks long.  He is absent, he wants me to sign for him to go on fieldtrips, he wants to call home to get something, he doesn’t bring his equipment, he doesn’t do the assignments.  He wants more time, he wants to email me the work (after the deadline).  He whines, he doesn’t feel good.  He’s hot, he’s tired, he’s thirsty.  It’s always something.  And, he’s a senior.

Yesterday, after not having the work for the week, nor starting the new assignment, he whined about about not wanting to work because it was a Friday.  I told him that in four years his teachers haven’t trained him very well.  He said it’s my job to educate him, not train him.  I agree, he should come to my class already trained to be a student so I don’t have to waste time training him but rather educating him.  Because, that’s what I want to do.  Instead, I have to do too much training.

4 responses to “Training vs educating

  1. Welcome to the Jungle! But I don’t think this problem is limited to Big City schools. I teach in a relatively comfortable suburb, and have almost exactly the same troubles. But I KNOW you can take your mind off those troubles tomorrow! Please don’t forget Sx3 tomorrow! Consider your funnybone tickled in advance!

  2. I think the problem is that PARENTS expect teachers to TRAIN their kids to be good students. When I was a kid, the parents expected teachers to teach content and expected their kids to behave themselves at school. They didn’t complain if you were punished for bad behavior, they punished you again for embarrassing them.

    The real issue in education today is not education, but parenting. Teachers are now the de facto parents of many kids. We are expected to teach them both content and behavior.

    Teachers really have only enough time in a day to do one or the other. I’m not blaming all parents, but unfortunately it only takes a couple of bad apples to ruin your classroom for all of them. Because if you spend all your time on one kid who is constantly acting up, you have a lot less time for the others.

  3. certainabsurdity's avatar certainabsurdity

    I completely agree with Teach J. I couldn’t have said it better myself.

  4. Here’s an update on the whiney young man–he cheated on the last assignment. He took someone’s flash drive, copied the filed, and made a few adjustments, but not enough to fool me. He was very indignant when I found it and pointed it out. “It was different than his.” Yeah, he changed the colors.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.